Cinnamon Overnight French Toast Bake Recipe - Fed & Fit (2024)

This cinnamon french toast bake is equal parts decadent and simple! It is perfect for brunch gatherings and special occasions like Christmas morning or Mother’s Day, because you can prepare it the night before, refrigerate it overnight, then bake it in the morning.

French toast is hands down, my favorite decadent breakfast, with an especially delicious blueberry pancake running a close second. As much as I love a perfect piece of french toast that is crisp on the outside with a rich, creamy texture on the inside, I tend to avoid making it in favor of easier breakfasts. Unless you have a large griddle, you’ll find yourself stuck standing at the stove for at least 30 minutes cooking one slice at a time. While that might be fine for a leisurely Sunday morning, I wanted to create something that was just as tasty but cut out the work.

I lovecasserolesfor all meals of the day, so I thought – why not make a french toast casserole? That’s exactly what baked french toast is. It’s a little like french toast, bread pudding, and cinnamon rolls had a baby and it has rocked my whole world. Best of ALL, it’s an absolute breeze to make. You can whip it up quickly for an easy breakfast, or you can prep it the night before for a no-fuss brunch.

Overnight French Toast Bake Ingredients

Like I said, this recipe is SIMPLE! You’ll only need a few ingredients for this delicious breakfast treat, and you probably already have them on hand! You’ll need bread, eggs, heavy cream, puremaple syrup, cinnamon, vanilla, and then powdered sugar for the luscious cinnamon roll glaze. While you’ll find that many recipes use whole milk, we found that heavy cream led to a deliciously rich texture that wasn’t overly soggy. We also opted for pure maple as our main sweetener because it complements the flavors of the dish so well!

What is the best bread for a French toast bake?

This recipe will be successful with whatever bread you have on hand! Since I’m gluten-free, I opted forCanyon Bakehouse Honey Whitebread, and it worked like a dream! If you don’t need to worry about gluten-free, brioche, challah, french bread or any crusty loaf of white bread would all make fantastic options.

How to Make Baked French Toast

Here’s how to make this simple french toast bake:

1. Lay your bread slices in a 9×13 baking dish.If you’re looking for a more bread pudding-style consistency, lay your slices of bread flat in a 9×13 pan, making sure they overlap. If a crispy top with a bread pudding consistency underneath is more your style, simply lay your loaf of bread in the pan at a diagonal angle.
2. Whisk the wet ingredients together.Whisk together the eggs, cream, maple syrup, cinnamon, and vanilla extract in a bowl until fully combined.
3. Pour the egg mixture over the bread.Once your wet ingredients are whisked, simply pour them over the bread into your pan.
4. Bake!Next, you’ll bake the casserole at 350 F for about 30 minutes, until the top of the bread is toasted and the liquid has been absorbed.
5. Make the cinnamon roll icing.Once the french toast has finished baking, it’s time to make the icing. Simply whisk together the powdered sugar, vanilla, and cream.
6. Pour the icing over top.Finally, the best part – pour the icing over the french toast bake and sprinkle cinnamon over top. Serve immediately and enjoy!

For an Overnight French Toast Bake

My preferred way to make this is the overnight method! It allows the bread to really soak up the liquid and leads to a great texture, plus it makes the next morning even easier! To make it overnight, simply assemble the casserole, cover it, then place it in the oven the next morning when you’re ready to eat.

How to Prevent Soggy Cinnamon French Toast

While it may feel a little bit risky to let your toast sit in liquid overnight, it actually won’t make for a soggy french toast. The use of heavy cream (vs. regular whole milk) also really helps to avoid a soggy texture here.

How to Serve

I love to serve this alongside some sort of breakfast protein (crispy oven bacon is my go-to) and eggs. The two of these really round out the meal!

How to Store, Freeze, and Reheat

Yes! This french toast bake freezes and reheats great. I’d recommend freezing a few slices at a time in an airtight container, or by wrapping the slices in wax paper then sealing in a Ziplock bag. You can quickly reheat them by microwaving for about 1 minute, or placing in a 350 F oven for 5-7 minutes. One thing to keep in mind here is that the icing will melt once reheated, but it will still taste great!

Frequently Asked Questions