Homemade Italian Dressing - I Heart Naptime (2024)

Make a spectacular homemade Italian dressing in as little as 5 minutes and always have a jar on hand as a fresh, bright, and flavorful way to dress up a salad or to use as a delicious and easy marinade!

This post may contain affiliate links. Read disclosure policy.

A Popular Tangy Vinaigrette

A simple homemade Italian dressing is something I love to keep on hand. It’s a zesty way to spruce up an Italian salad, but it is also one of my favorite marinades for grilled chicken. It’s nice and light so it works with Italian tortellini pasta salad as well as Antipasto salad without any heavy cream weighing it down.

Knowing how to make an Italian dressing from scratch is something every home cook should know. Kids LOVE it and if a good dressing means eating more salads, then it’s definitely a win!

It’s a pure and simple zesty vinaigrette made with olive oil, red wine vinegar, and loads of herbs and spices, most of which can be found in an Italian seasoning blend for convenience. There’s nothing complicated about this dressing, which means it’s super simple to make to keep on hand, and whenever I run out, I can make it again in a pinch. Hop on the homemade dressing train, trust me you’ll never look back!

Is Homemade Italian Salad Dressing Healthy?

Making a homemade dressing from scratch is almost always healthier than using store-bought. I mean sure, sometimes it’s super convenient to grab a bottle already made, but have you ever wondered why they have such a long shelf life? It’s because of all the added sodium, preservatives, additives, and sugar!

A homemade Italian dressing allows you to control what you put in and what you keep out. A good quality olive, cold-pressed, extra virgin olive oil has a subtle flavor but also nutritional benefits such as antioxidants and helps to maintain good cholesterol. Store-bought dressings don’t tend to use high-quality ingredients as a way to keep their costs down. Think about it the next time you reach for a bottle at the store. Homemade dressing all the way!

Variations for this Italian Dressing Recipe

• Add 1/4 cup of freshly grated parmesan for extra flavor.
• Throw in a scoop of Dijon mustard for a kick.
• Use white wine vinegar for a slightly different taste.
• Add both mayonnaise and parmesan cheese for a creamier texture, similar to this Olive Garden salad dressing.
• Add 1-2 teaspoons of sugar or honey for added sweetness if you’re not a fan of tangy dressings.

What Else Can I Use it For?

• As a dressing: For kale quinoa salad, caprese salad, Greek salad, and as an alternative to balsamic dressing in this steak salad.
• To marinade: Perfect for grilled chickenand grilled steak kabobs.
• For a creamy topping: When you add the parmesan and mayo combo, it’s a delicious topping for Italian burgers, a dip for grilled veggies, and a drizzle on top of burger in a bowl.

Storage Tips

Add all of your ingredients to a cute little mason jar, shake, and store with a lid for up to 14 days. That way you can use it to store and serve, even your guests, without dirtying up extra dishes. If you added parm or mayo to your dressing, it will keep fresh in the fridge for about 1 week.

More Homemade Dressing Recipes

HUNGRY FOR MORE? Subscribe to my newsletter and follow on Facebook, Pinterest and Instagram for all the newest recipes!